Our first afternoon on St. Thomas disappeared into a rental-car problem, and by the time we had a vehicle, we had to drive straight to the dock for a sunset cruise. So, how many days do you need in St. Thomas? We had three, counting that arrival day, before taking the car ferry to St. John. Here’s what actually fit—and where the time went.
Three days, but only two full days to explore
This was a Covid-era trip, so the entry checks, mask rules and lack of cruise ships we encountered describe that visit, not what you should expect now. Our first day was mostly travel, with a sunset catamaran cruise squeezed in at the end. The next day was Charlotte Amalie and a snorkel trip; day three was Kelly’s birthday and our beach-hopping day. The following morning, we left from Red Hook on the car ferry.
Those two full days covered the old town, the water and a handful of beaches. If you’re choosing how long to stay, counting your arrival day as a full day would make a trip like ours sound much roomier than it was.
Day one: From the airport to a sunset cruise
After landing, we lined up for the Covid-test check required at the time. That part went smoothly. Getting our rental car was another matter. The company we’d booked with was off-airport, and we couldn’t reach its shuttle by phone. None of the rental desks at the airport had a car available, so Kevin took a taxi to the off-airport location while Kelly waited at the airport with the bags. More than an hour later, he was still in line.
We did get a vehicle, but there was no time to settle in first: we drove straight to the dock for a sunset cruise on the VI Cat. Kevin had an old friend on the island who worked on the catamaran, and we went for drinks with friends afterward. Then we got a little lost finding our Airbnb on St. Thomas’s winding roads. Our small studio had a bed and kitchenette, and we reached it close to 10 p.m. Not quite the relaxed first afternoon we might have pictured.

What driving on St. Thomas was like for us
If you rent a car, be comfortable driving it. The driver sits on the left, as in a typical American car, but traffic drives on the left side of the road. That took some getting used to; so did the steep, narrow, winding streets. On our drive into Charlotte Amalie, one turn was tight enough to require a three-point turn. We also encountered construction while driving between beaches.
Our rental turned out to be a dinged-up island truck with a grate on the back. We thought it might be all-wheel drive, and it served us well on those roads—well enough that we grew attached to it. Taxis were an option, but we liked being able to explore at our own pace. If driving those roads sounds more stressful than freeing, that’s worth considering before you rent. We pass along a few more lessons from the same trip in our Helpful Tips For Your U.S. Virgin Islands Vacation post.
Day two: Charlotte Amalie, snorkeling and Lime Tree Beach
We met Kevin’s friend, who lives on St. Thomas, for coffee and a walk through Charlotte Amalie. She took us to some of her favorite spots, including Palm Passage, a courtyard with shops. We wandered the colorful old streets, took photos and came away with a macramé purse bought as an early birthday present. At the time, cruise ships hadn’t called for about a year, and the streets felt unusually empty. It was lovely for photos, though hardly good for the businesses.

The humidity eventually sent us back to the truck to sit in the air-conditioning before our afternoon snorkel cruise. The VI Cat leaves from the Marriott’s Frenchman’s Cove, and there are two Marriotts on the island, so make sure you head to the right one. From there we went to Turtle Cove at Little Buck Island, hoping to see turtles. We didn’t see any, but we did see coral reefs and an eagle ray that, naturally, we didn’t manage to film.

After the cruise, we headed to Lime Tree Beach on our friend’s recommendation. It sits at a resort, but all beaches in the Virgin Islands are public. We finished with an outdoor dinner with friends, which we didn’t film.
Day three: A birthday at Magens Bay and beyond
We started Kelly’s birthday with breakfast sandwiches and coffee from Northside Grind, a place a friend had recommended near Magens Bay, and brought them down to the beach. Magens had restrooms, picnic tables and a beach bar on our visit, so it was easy to spend a few hours there. It isn’t especially wide, but it’s long enough that we found room to spread out, even though it was still fairly busy without cruise-ship visitors.

Next we drove to Coki Beach. It was a nice beach, but much smaller, with people more concentrated together. Hardly anyone was wearing a mask on our Covid-era visit, so we decided to move on. Finding lunch became more work than it needed to be: local places we tried were busy or closed, and we ended up at Margaritaville. The food was surprisingly good, but looking back, we should have eaten at Magens Bay instead of spending more time driving around looking for somewhere to eat.
After a shower at the Airbnb, we drove up to the top of Paradise Point for sunset. The road was another adventure, but the view of the surrounding islands and Charlotte Amalie’s boats and yachts was worth it. We finished the birthday with dinner by the water, excellent garlic bread and a chocolate soufflé cake. It was our highlights-of-St.-Thomas day, even if our lunch plan needed work.

Departure morning: Taking the car ferry to St. John
The next morning, we headed to Red Hook on the east side of St. Thomas. We’d changed our plan to rent another car on St. John because we liked our island truck enough to take it with us. There was also a passenger ferry, but with the truck, we joined the car-ferry line without a reservation.
Instructions were scarce, one ferry left, and we waited for the next barge. When it was our turn, Kevin reversed the truck aboard just after a semi. That was the easy position: some cars we’d watched had to squeeze into the remaining spaces. Ours still ended up about six inches from the car beside it. By our reckoning, it took about two hours from arriving at Red Hook to pushing off; we expected the crossing itself to take roughly twenty to thirty minutes.
We bought a one-way ticket so we could choose whichever barge worked for our return rather than tie ourselves to one company. Our advice at the time was not to bother with a reservation, because the barges load first come, first served and a full barge means waiting for the next one either way; check how the operators handle it now. For current ferry fares and schedules, tour details, beach fees and entry rules, check with the ferry operators, the VI Cat and the relevant official pages before you travel.
So, how many days would we allow?
Our three days gave us two full days to explore St. Thomas, plus a sunset cruise on arrival day. If you want a trip like ours, protect those two full days rather than assuming you’ll have much sightseeing time after your flight. We’d also eat at Magens Bay instead of turning lunch into another drive, and allow a generous stretch of the next morning for the car ferry. Our recommendation, which is not how long our own visit lasted: for a first-time visitor who wants beaches, sightseeing and a boat excursion, three full days would be a comfortable choice.
If you’re flying home from St. Thomas, don’t count on a final bonus beach hour without checking your airport timing, either. We were told to arrive three hours before departure, and getting through ticketing, customs and baggage took us a couple of hours. The Paradise Point sunset was the one thing we’d say was definitely worth the drive. Three days worked, but the arrival day barely counted as one.
Image credits: the photo of Magens Bay used as the featured image is by MARELBU, licensed CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons (source). We resized it from the original and made no other changes. That photo was not taken on our trip. The other photos are stills from our own videos of St. Thomas.